Did you miss Round One? Do you still need a bracket? Those links will help you catch up. And now onward…


Jump to: (3) Tessa Thompson vs. (6) Jackie Cruz


Teyana downed Nafessa Williams with 66 percent of the vote, and Katy Perry easily swatted aside Rachel Weisz with 92 percent of the vote, setting up this clash of eyesores between two women who really know how to COMMIT to a look. I’ve tried to dig up some never-before-seen contenders for you here, but I have to begin with the most obvious case in point: Katy Perry, using — as we noted at the time — the bare minimum of Catholic imagination to cohost a Met Gala party celebrating fashion and the Catholic imagination.

Celebrities Arrive at the Metropolitan Museum of Art Costume Institute Benefit Gala 2018

This isn’t the best shot of the outfit, but it’s hilarious. This whole slideshow is a fun ride, actually; I highly recommend starting here and then lugging your own wings down memory lane.

Teyana, too, can lean into a costume.

Embed from Getty Images

Indeed, she is both LITERALLY leaning, and also possibly wearing an athletic supporter? Seriously, is that a cup in there?

Katy wore minty wings as well this year, and then this purple floofy confection:

Embed from Getty Images

Teyana wore… athletic chaps?

2018 MTV Video Music Awards

This post is long, by the way, but I think you are going to enjoy the shit out of it. There is SO MUCH. Look, Katy dressed up as Kaley Cuoco dressing up as a Barbie:

QVC Presents FFANY Shoes On Sale

Teyana looks like a Foxy Boxing ref:

Alexander Wang Collection 2 show, Fall 2019, New York, USA - 01 Dec 2018

Katy, while hosting American Idol, showed up on-screen and on the red carpet — for a very large national audience — in a series of bizarre getups that I hadn’t seen because, with apologies to Lionel, I did not say HELLO to the reboot. Here is one:

Embed from Getty Images

Is that inspired by Endora, a Golden Girl, an episode of the Love Boat, or all three?

Teyana would like another chance to confuse you, and far be it from me to deny her:

Embed from Getty Images

Katy has a ruffled cape for you to consider:

Embed from Getty Images

Teyana has confusing pants, although that jacket looks great on her:

amfAR's 25th Cinema Against AIDS Gala, Arrivals, 71st Cannes Film Festival, France - 17 May 2018

Katy has Christian Siriano custom-make this for her, and I do not know on whose end the grievous error occurred, but IT DID OCCUR:

Embed from Getty Images

Her BOOTS have their own KNEEPADS. Or are those naplins? Kneepkins? WHAT.

Teyana, care to comment?

Embed from Getty Images


(In fairness, she was at an Uggs anniversary party, but it still takes a special kind of moxie to pick Uggs that are also essentially pants, and yet also OVER pants.)

Embed from Getty Images

Is this… is she in costume as Cher? Because she did show up to American Idol dressed as Snow White, so anything is possible.

Are we done?

Levi's Neon Carnival, Thermal, USA - 14 Apr 2018

Never. No, seriously, never. We will never finish.

Celebrities at the 'Jimmy Kimmel Live!' studios


Teyana Taylor hosts at Apex Social Club for Labor Day Weekend, Palms Resort and Casino, Las Vegas, USA - 31 Aug 2018

Teyana’s commitment is clearly to her own abs, which… if I thought I could do that to my abs, I would also marry her fitness regimen.

Katy, you’re the higher seed here. Defend your territory with the last word.

Katy Perry out and about, New York, USA - 30 Oct 2018

Okay. NOW, for the time being, temporarily, we are finished simply because we need to VOTE THIS THING OUT.

Archives: Katy Perry, Teyana Taylor

Whose fug reigns supreme?

  • Katy Perry (53%, 2,953 Votes)
  • Teyana Taylor (47%, 2,627 Votes)

Total Voters: 5,580

Loading ... Loading ...


This is one of my favorite clashes — in fact, this entire post has been a freaking delight that validates what the hell Jessica and I are even doing here. There is so much awful clothing to celebrate, through a combination of shock and awe and helpless mirth or helpless horror. YAY. However, I wrote this whole thing and my browser cruelly ate it. I don’t know when, I don’t know how, but I know I AM SCREAMING RIGHT NOOOOOOOOW. Please just trust that it was great before, and now it is… present and accounted for, at least?

Anyway, Tessa Thompson tries to be very high fashion; Jackie Cruz just tries to be very high energy. Both earned the hell out of their spot here, and this one ought to be supremely entertaining, if I reconstituted it correctly.

Let’s give the ball to Jackie first:

iHeart Radio Music Awards, Arrivals, Los Angeles, USA - 11 Mar 2018

Oh, and remember this jumpsuit from the Harper’s Bazaar Icons party? It must really be hers, and she must REALLY love it, because she repeated it at some Ritz Carlton opening a few months later at which Coco Rocha danced in her face or something?

Embed from Getty Images

It’s all very confusing. As is this confection from a Grammy afterparty:

Embed from Getty Images

I’d kind of like to see that jacket styled with… oh, anything else.

Belvedere Vodka launches Laolu Senbanjo Limited Edition bottle, New York, USA - 06 Sep 2018

That’s fairly run-of-the-mill by comparison, but it shows that even the basics are going awry. It just doesn’t seem to fit very well and it’s doing nothing for her. Certainly the same could be said about this sucker:

InStyle and Warner Bros Golden Globes After Party, Arrivals, Los Angeles, USA - 06 Jan 2019

Many of you wondered if this is the same dress as Tracee Ellis Ross’s pink Emmys gown, and it is NOT — it’s a different designer completely. Which means that people are knocking off that big ol’ thing, and then making it worse.

This is from her ice dancing side hustle:

The Variety and Women in Film Emmy Party

I need help with this one:

Netflix FYSee Kick-Off Event, Arrivals, Los Angeles, USA - 06 May 2018

Is that… beige FABRIC, or her skin coming through a cutout? My feelings are quite dependent on the answer.

And now for Jackie’s final word on the matter:

'Miss Bala' Film Premiere, Roaming Arrivals, Regal L.A. Live, Los Angeles, USA - 30 Jan 2019

Thank you, my dear. Go on and wait in the lobby, and we’ll call you back in when we’ve made a decision.

Now, on to Tessa. She wore plastic shoes to the Independent Spirit Awards, so she and Jackie clearly would not provide a shoe intervention for each other. That oatmeal-hued costume was also not her only foray into Ren Faire fashion, if you can believe it:

Embed from Getty Images

The best part is, I believe this next photo was shot on the way IN to Kimmel and it’s a whole DIFFERENT insane outfit:

'Jimmy Kimmel Live!' TV show, Los Angeles, USA - 13 Nov 2018

We also haven’t seen this before:

Embed from Getty Images

That skirt looks comfortable to sit in, at least, like she has bench seating in her dining room and decided to wear the cushion.

If you were unmoved by her black and gold Chanel at the Oscars, you may rethink that opinion once you see the Chanel for which she discarded it:

Vanity Fair Oscar Party, Arrivals, Los Angeles, USA - 24 Feb 2019

Of course, she also wore a Chanel bag as a necklace, so her decisions where Karl is koncerned are klearly kloudy.

This is new information, and will ALARM YOU GREATLY:

AOL Build Speaker Series, New York, USA - 20 Jun 2018

Look at all of it. The shoulder, in particular. It’s disintegrating before our very eyes.

Tessa Thompson out and about, New York, USA - 10 May 2018

The optical illusion in this photo that she has a third leg, or some kind of back-end kick-stand, is really special. The outfit itself is a horror show that’s unfinished around the pant hems.

At least it’s not sheer, unlike this:

'Fahrenheit 451' film premiere, Arrivals, New York, USA - 08 May 2018

I was going to make that the final MIC DROP moment of this piece…

9th Annual Bombay Sapphire Artisan Series Finale, Art Basel, Miami, Florida, USA - 06 Dec 2018

…but then I realized it cannot be, as long as THIS photo exists:

Premiere of Sorry To Bother You During Opening of 10th Annual BAMcinemaFest

Consider that mic dropped, picked up, and then dropped again. Harder. With MIGHT.

Archives: Tessa Thompson, Jackie Cruz

Whose fug reigns supreme?

  • Tessa Thompson (55%, 2,861 Votes)
  • Jackie Cruz (45%, 2,328 Votes)

Total Voters: 5,189

Loading ... Loading ...