I was about to joke that SJP and the And Just Like That… team are staging fake shoots in absurd costumes just to mess with everyone, because they know how much paparazzi attention this gets. And then I saw that our pals Tom and Lorenzo ALSO had that reaction. It seems implausible — who has TIME for something like that?!? — and yet it’s also completely plausible, because it’s the only sensible explanation. SURELY Carrie is not suddenly doing weird I Love Lucy cosplay?

[Photos: Shutterstock]