This probably would have been a Well Played, had she just chopped off her legs at the ankles and trotted around like a double peg-legged pirate. What, you think I’m exaggerating? Maybe. But the shoes she chose were the footwear equivalent of bloody stumps, to me, and it derailed this whole train. Like Dementors attacking the Hogwarts Express, but less chilly and with fewer hoodies.

Let her have it:

  • It's amazing, full stop (28%, 2,175 Votes)
  • It's amazing until we get to the shoes (55%, 4,328 Votes)
  • The whole thing is worse than that time Joey Potter sang her mugger to death (18%, 1,398 Votes)

Total Voters: 7,903

Loading ... Loading ...

And that other one?

  • Yay! (16%, 921 Votes)
  • Yeeeahhhh....? (44%, 2,591 Votes)
  • Yikes (40%, 2,366 Votes)

Total Voters: 5,878

Loading ... Loading ...

[Photos: Getty]