I know Katie Holmes still looks a lot like she did back in her Dawson’s Creek days, but that’s absolutely NO reason to revisit the fashion lunacy of that era. I honestly don’t even know if this counts as Of That Era — it’s marooned on a desolate, cruel island somewhere between “going-out top” and “dress over pants,” an island where not even the Lost plane wants to crash. In fact, this is how I feel about this outfit:

dawson crying-1670789121

At least there’s some Lizzo in here to cheer us all up.

[Photos: Gregory Pace, Erik Pendzich, Kristin Callahan/Shutterstock, Charles Sykes/Invision/AP/Shutterstock]