Good news, or bad news depending on how you view it: Vanessa Hudgens has toned things down since deploying her very lacy semi-“Like a Virgin” gown at the first Tick, Tick… Boom! screening. I’ve seen a variety of reactions, including “mediocre” and “Andrew Garfield can’t carry it” to “it’s great and Andrew Garfield is fantastic.” What I’m getting at is, I hope this thing has legs because I’d LOVE to see Vanessa Hudgens put together a whole awards season run, wouldn’t you?

[Photos: Raymond Hall/GC Images, Alberto E. Rodriguez/Getty Images, Gotham/GC Images, Robert Kamau/GC Images, Gregory Pace/Shutterstock, J Mayer/Shutterstock]