A dollar for the number of times I thought, “WAIT, is that JC Chasez?!” while watching last night’s telecast. So, sure, I’d only have two bucks, but still. Also: Velvet! Sequins! CLOUDS!

[Photos: Adela Loconte/Variety via Getty Images, Dia Dipasupil/WireImage, Kristina Bumphrey/WWD via Getty Images, kena betancur / AFP via Getty Images, Mike Coppola/Getty Images for Tony Awards Productions, Jamie McCarthy/Getty Images]