Lily Collins We JUST saw Michaela Coel yesterday in a shirt that looks like this, and now we have a gown version of I Got Stuck And Couldn't Get It Over My Head. Did we need either? Ashley Park They seem truly a little bit formal for PaleyFest

Michaela Coel This is overbaked. I'd clip the light blue sleeves, and ideally would not have dropped the waist to below her butt, but I suppose we can't have everything. Also, does this need white boots instead of black? The whole thing is trying way too

Amy Madigan! Well, that hat does feel ripped from a painting. Or a chef's house. Or a painting of a chef's house. Talk Elle Fanning into it! Meryl could pull off this sharp tailoring on top, but maybe not the trousers. The shoes are so unserious.

Rowan Blanchard Well. That's gonna leave a mark. Lucy Halliday I don't know if I think this was enhanced at all by making it so... diagonal. There's enough going on without it needing to seem a bit cockeyed. Ann Dowd I LOVE this cape

Jon Hamm and Anna Osceola I would rather see Jon Hamm get an arc on Shrinking, or being an astronaut on For All Mankind, or something. He's still got it. Anna looks cute until her plastic shoes. Make opacity cool again. Amanda Peet I have always liked Amanda

Nelly Furtado in Alexis Bittar This could maybe do with a necklace, but otherwise, I think this is smashing. Sarah McLachlan It's so nice to see her. Fumbling Toward Ecstasy is SUCH a good album. And it's been long enough since I've seen one

Brandy It's perfect for clambering down to the ground for a photo op that won't flash everyone, but the sweater looks like she was trying to knit an Elizabethan shirt and got turned around. Monica and Brandy I like Brandy's ensemble better from this