Fug Madness 2012: The Final Game


In the post for last season’s One Fugging Moment montage, Heather wrote, “Vanessa Hudgens, your destiny may await.” Hudgens, that knock at the door you just heard is destiny, and she’s finally here. But you’re going to have to go through Lindsay Lohan to get to her.

PS: Voting is only open from now, until 9:00am on April 3, Pacific time, so VOTE NOW.

Whose fug reigns supreme?

  • Lilo (50%, 7,276 Votes)
  • Vanessa Hudgens (50%, 7,370 Votes)

Total Voters: 14,633

Loading ... Loading ...
react:
Leave a reply

Comments (243):

  1. Katharine
    0

    I didn’t want to vote for Lindsay, but in the end, I had to. I live in a town with two universities, and Vanessa, seriously, on the Real World scale, is no fugger than 90% of the female students I see shopping at the local groceries. It’s fair to argue that in her position it might behoove her to hire a professional to hone her image — but, you know, I can’t fault her for looking like her age mates.

    Lilo, on the other hand… looks like the tragedy she is.

    • gladly
      0

      I like that Hudgens looks pleasantly insane. Like, if Steven Tyler really was your nutty pottery teacher who somehow ended up on American Idol, this is what he would have looked like as a young woman. So, yes, it’s bad, but I find it inoffensively so.

      Lindsay Lohan makes me full on sad. For her, Fug Madness is too literal to be much fun. I’m stuck on this pairing.

      • nuna
        0

        Hey Gladly, I could not have put it better. My feelings exactly.

      • Hani G
        0

        This is exactly how I felt.

        But in the end I voted for Lilo on the grounds that even without the sad things she’s done to her face I still think the clothes are awful and that’s what she’s choosing to wear.

      • Kayla
        0

        I completely agree. At least Vanessa looks like she might be an insane delight. Lindsay is just full-on, unmedicated insane. I feel for her, I really do, but get it together girl. Showering is the first step.

    • Ken D
      0

      Agreed. Lilo has been in the limelight for a long time while VH is just starting out. Lilo should know better while VH is just a kid trying to fit in with her peers. Did anyone else notice that VH has fat thighs?

      • Alle Hall
        0

        Oh, that’s mean. She’s a little kid.

        I think a vote for Lohan is really a vote for her fug life. Is this fair? GFY stopped covering Brittney when she sent down.

        Which is not to say I won’t vote for Lohan….. I am torn … Nope. I going for the little one. I forget her name a lot. I am pretty old. Thanks for listening.

      • Heather C
        0

        Not cool, we’re here to judge the fug, not the physical. VH is probably a 2 in real life and I for one appreciate starlets who aren’t afraid of the occasional sandwich. I’m sick of looking at clavicles and rib bones.

      • V
        0

        @Ken D –That is called muscle. Most celebrities don’t have it… VH has awesome legs!! Now, if only she’d dress them better…

        Back on topic :) — I think my vote has to go to Lilo. And it isn’t just the clothes, it is the fug that she has done to her own face and hair. She could be a cute girl in ugly clothes (like VH)- but she has made herself fugly.

      • Lizzie T
        0

        We do NOT make negative comments on bodies here at GFY. Just the clothes and how they FIT the bodies that wear them. Thanks.

        VH has an adorable figure and a lovely face and I DELIGHT in her fuggery!

    • Cynthia Coles
      0

      @Katherine, I have to agree. I was just at the courtyard shared by Art Institute and Devry here in Atlanta earlier today and Vanessa would fit right in.

      Lilo, on the other hand, is a tragedy. The dimpling around her knees? Ok, I just turned 50 on Saturday and I have the same problem. I am almost old enough to be her Grandma. Srsly. We should not have the same body issues.

      Voted for Linds.

  2. The Other Molly
    0

    I’m still mystified as to how it came down to these two.
    I agree with Katharine.
    Hudgens never should have made it this far.
    Her fug is unworthy.

    • Kellilee
      0

      Agreed. I looked at all the competitors and thought, “Really? These two?”

      • TaraMisu
        0

        Yep, agreeance. I keeping shaking my head and going back over the brackets wondering wth happened.

    • dvj
      0

      This happened b/c The Sev knocked out Miley. Miley is the true representative of trying to look fun and young and naked (more than the average college student), and just looking gross. Plus desperate, miserable efforts at sophistication on the red carpet.

      But not life tragic, like LiLo. I can’t vote Fug Life in the final.

  3. Talley
    0

    I had to vote for Lilo, even tho it still feels like kicking a girl when she’s down. Vanessa has some prodigious fug, but that face does a lot to mitigate what’s happening below her neck. Lilo’s face should be capable of the same kind of rescue, but it just isn’t anymore. What has she done to herself?!

    • Softwear
      0

      This is exactly why I ended up voting for Lindsay, against my expectations. Based solely on the fugness of her lips and hair. The outfits are all bad in every case. But Hudge still has her original lips. So Lindsay takes it.

      • ESK
        0

        I had to give my vote to Lohan on this one, strictly based on the fact that her fugs come on red carpets, when, theoretically, she’s making an effort to get it right and knows she will be photographed. (And failing miserable.) Whereas most of V’s fugs come from her personal life, when she’s probably not expecting to be caught on film.

    • Karen G
      0

      I’m also voting for Lilo based on the face fuggery. At least Vanessa is smart enough not to screw with her face, even if she does make some truly hideous fashion choices. Clothing wise, they’re probably equally fuggy, but Lilo wins by a nose – I mean, by lips and cheeks.

  4. Karen
    0

    Still cannot vote for LiLo, she is tragic in an unfunny way. Vanessa, on the other hand, is funny as hell.

    • Laura E.
      0

      Exactly. A vote for Vanessa is a vote for fun fuggery. Do we want to reward the sadness that is Lindsay Lohan? Hudge!

      • Fanl
        0

        YES to the both of you. Fun/funny fug, not intervention fug.

      • Mahastee
        0

        So agree, I am saddened that Lilo has made it this far in Fug Madness (or that she was even included, for that matter).

        Not cool to make fun of those in a spiral of despair, I’m sure it’ll be so hilarious when she’s dead from an overdose.

    • natalia
      0

      YES!

  5. Cranky Old Batt
    0

    This is tough. They both grate on me sartorially. But at least one is not known for also being a criminal. So by the narrowest of margins, Lilo, you are the fugliest of them all.

  6. Improbable Joe
    0

    The power of Fug compels you!
    The power of Fug compels you!
    The power of Fug compels you!
    The power of Fug compels you!

    … to vote Lilo all the way!

  7. Fug de los Muertos
    0

    I voted for Lindsay because I think The Hudge got it right at least twice last year. That’s 200% more times than Lindsay did.

  8. EHobbes
    0

    Lilo: slide #8:: Ashanti: Vagina Sling…that get-up takes her far – and puts her over the top – in fugliness.

  9. ivana
    0

    You see, these final two just make me sad. It’s just not fun to snicker about what Lindsay is wearing…she seems like someone who is confused and in a lot of pain. It just takes the fun out of the fug…and I know fug is not supposed to be mean-spirited. Vanessa, to me, seems like Lindsay a few years ago, and can just as easily fall into the same kind of spiral Lindsay has gotten herself into. Sorry to be all Debbie Downer about it…

    • CranAppleSnapple
      0

      I don’t think Lilo realises she is confused, in that she is a delusional narcissist with outrageous delusions of grandeur. She thinks we ENVY her beauty and style. That makes me want to hang a big thumping bedazzled banner around her neck that says **FUG!!**, in allcaps.

    • Jessica
      0

      Vanessa is fine, I think. She works all the time, she has a nice boyfriend, she’s never gotten arrested, there was not a SINGLE paps shot of her at a club — or you’d have seen it here. Ugly pants isn’t a predictor for substance abuse problems.

  10. Rebekah
    0

    I’m with Karen. LiLo’s fug is just an outgrowth of her tragic self. But Vanessa seems so PLEASED with those lace bellbottoms and pink shawls. I love it.

    • Kat
      0

      That’s EXACTLY why she got my vote. You know she’s thinking, “God, look how hip retro awesome I look. These lace pants are the SHIZ.” Okay, maybe not those exact words, but she seems pretty proud of her heinous choices, and she has no inner demons to blame like LiLo does.

  11. Kit
    0

    So funny! I looked at all of Lindsey’s and thought – my god, Vanessa can’t be THAT bad. And then I saw Vanessa’s cumulative effort and thought well, apparently, she can. There’s just TOO. MUCH. BAD to outweigh the not so good.

  12. Fiona K
    0

    Too Hard! Had to choose Vanessa because Lilo is self destructing in slo-mo and it makes me sad.

  13. Squirrel!
    0

    Yowza. At 09:35 PST, it’s 394 votes for LiLo vs. 396 for VHudge.

  14. Christian
    0

    Wow, it’s 50/50! This goes against my earlier postings about Lindsay in previous matches, but as someone who had a drug problem in 2003 – 2004, I can definitely say that drugs make you think some SERIOUSLY awful clothing looks awesome. So I voted for Vanessa, because she seems like she doesn’t stray beyond the normal vices and still puts on some heinous crap and thinks it looks good.

  15. Cassandra
    0

    I would so watch Switched by the Bell.

  16. Sylvia
    0

    Lace pants. LACE, BELL-BOTTOM PANTS!!! And a cross that hangs over a vagina. Folks, Lindsay Lohan is a girl with mother (and father) issues who looks like her mother. You pray she lives long enough to write a tell-all, you do not reward her. Her fug is internal. She fixes her psyche, she fixes her clothes. The Hudgens has no hope. She had a pretty stable family life from what I’ve read. There’s no excuse. Her best outfits may have been in High School Musical. She was her least offensive when being dressed by others at 16. It gets worse as she gets older. I have to vote for that. It’s a tragedy we can laugh at together.

    • FashionShowAtLunch
      0

      Yes. The lace bell-bottom pants. That is her equivalent of the vagina-sling. It guarantees her a place in the fug hall of shame.

      • ok
        0

        Lohan’s fug is pretty strong, but it pales in comparison to those lace pants. That picture of Hudgens burns my eyes, as opposed to just making me wrinkle my nose in disgust.

  17. laura
    0

    The Hudge all the way! As fugtastic as Lindsay is, just can’t vote for her…too sad. As others pointed out, Vanessa actually looks happy with what’s she’s wearing, and that my friends is just plain wrong!

  18. Frances
    0

    OMG! OMG! 50 – 50 split right now! I am hyperventilating!

    Ha ha ha. I absolutely had to vote for V-Hugs because she brought it to the competition, and I just can’t kick at Lindsay right now. She is so obviously ill with no one trying to help her. I just can’t. Plus, Vanessa is definitely a worthy winner – for the jean overalls alone.

  19. Edith
    0

    I love a barn-burner! So exciting!

    Lilo all the way. THE SKIRT IN SLIDE THREE ALSO HAS HAIR, around the back. SHE HAD TO COMB HER SKIRT. And the hair on her skirt looks a million times healthier and more attractive than the hair on her head.

    • Edith
      0

      Upon closer inspection, I think that the hair on the skirt is actually on the sweater thingee, which must be longer than I originally thought. NO MATTER. Long, luxurious HAIR around the cuffs and hem of her sweater.

      Enough with the pity. There aren’t enough drugs in the world to excuse that sweater.

  20. Indiana Douche
    0

    This is a tough one. If Hudgens had been beaten by Ke$ha, I would have gone with Ke$ha over LiLo. But it has to be LiLo FTW.

  21. FashionShowAtLunch
    0

    I still just feel way too sad for LiLo to vote for her here.

    Hudge is just blissfully and cheerfully ignorant of her fug, but LiLo still seems completely freaking out of it.

  22. currygirl
    0

    This is easy…vote for the fun FUG! Hudgens and her pants of insanity ALL THE WAY!

  23. Jill
    0

    I really thought The Hudge Would. Go. All. The. Way. But in the end I have to vote for LiLo yet again, for the fact that she’s permanently fugged her face. I’m reading that some find her sad, no one forced her to go under the knife. Or to put on ugly clothes or nasty hair extensions. I hope one day she finds her way back, but even if she does, she’ll still be wearing someone else’s face.

    • Kit
      0

      We’re not supposed to be voting for someone’s FACE (that seems way too cruel even for we who delight in being b***tchy about everyone and anyone’s clothes). I mean seriously – “You win fug madness because you’re UGLY sistah!” is not what this site is about.

      (At least, I sincerely hope that’s the case.)

  24. ccm800
    0

    VH for two reasons ONE she deserves it. TWO Lilo should be on attention getting hiatus. The more press she gets the worse she plummets. Just to maybe save this child…lets ignore her until she has nothing left to do but get the damn help she needs.

  25. Sophia Loren
    0

    Feel good about voting for Vanessa! She consistently takes something very cool and buries it under a huge pile of fug. It’s a talent that should be recognized!

    For example, in slide 9: the shoes are cute, in 10: the fabric pattern is rather sophisticated. 11: the skirt, again, has a fabric that Diane Kruger could work. In 12 &13 : the leather jacket and the leather and shearling jacket would both look great with the kind of jeans or pants other people wear. 16: tell me honestly that you don’t want silky snakeskin pjs, for at home. 20: the boots, 21: the sweater, and 22: the belt.

    All things I’d love to have in my closet. Yet part of something so very fugly in that fun, youthful Hudgens way.

    And we can leave poor Lindsay out of this.

  26. Molly
    0

    I voted for Lilo based on the entirely unscientific evidence that previous winners go away for a while and get themselves into a better place. Go Lilo! Go all the way!!

    (seriously, go)

    • EmSpeaks
      0

      Voted for her for the same reason!

      • annek
        0

        I voted for Lilo earlier for this reason — the girlfriend-needs-some-time-off reason –but then I thought, oh no, what if she disappears because she DIES! then I would feel I had contributed to her downfall.

    • Dani
      0

      I voted for Hudge, because I don’t think she has the self esteem issues and still choses to dress crazy, but was happy for Lilo to take the crown for the same reason. Some time away would be best for all, I think.

  27. Willow
    0

    OMG! This is going to be TIGHT! Hoping that the Hudge takes it because I feel that she may snap out of her FugRut and start dressing nicely again so this might be her only shot, but I’m happy either way.

  28. Scott
    0

    Have just returned from a lengthy internet-free trip, and am saddened that I missed the complete run up to the final two. I’m also surprised that people are putting Vanessa in the same category as Lilo. Vanessa, while indeed wearing some whacked-out crap, is going through her age-appropriate outfit rebellion period. If she passed me on a college campus wearing any of those outfits, I’d hardly blink. Lindsay, on the other hand, is wearing her cougar-trolling-for-the-next-Ashton ensemble, and failing at that.

    • Edith
      0

      YES. THIS.

    • Kit
      0

      Everyone keeps saying that, but I completed two degrees on two different campuses, and I swear to god, I NEVER say anyone as cractacular as Vanessa on either of my campuses!

  29. jen310
    0

    Holy frijoles, it is a dead tie between them – 50% to 50%. That’s awesome. I thought I’d vote for LiLo but, upon sober reflection, I feel that the Hugde’s sartorial crimes are much greater then hers. Why? Cuz that’s just how LiLo rolls. LiLo is beyond fug at this point. Her whole life is one big mess and winning the fug crown is not gonna change it. Lilo is beyond the point of no return by at least 1000 miles.
    The Hudge doesn’t know what style is but she can be helped. Winning Fug Madness might be exactly what she needs. She can change, she has potential, and I honestly think that she deserves this more. I want the Hugde to win. Hudge 2012!!!!!!!
    Truth be told, I’d be happy if either one of these fugsters took home the championship and I cannot wait to see the One Fugging Moment montage. Fug Madness is just too fugging fun.
    Viva le Fug Madness.

    • Grace
      0

      Totally agree about Fug Madness! Here in Australia, I have spent the last while suffering through exams. Checking out the latest match-ups is my haven from studying, so thankyou for making me giggle away when otherwise I would be close to pulling out my hair.

      On another note, Lilo 2012. There is some fuggery so blatant and heinously inbuilt in her that I just couldn’t bring myself to click my life away to Hudge and her lace pants of doom.

  30. Sandra
    0

    That see-through shirt of LiLo’s scarred my retinas more than Vanessa’s lace pants, so LiLo FTW. Not that those pants aren’t bad, mind you.

  31. leah
    0

    I totally disagree with the people who are surprised that these are the two finalists. These girls don’t even realize how fugly they are, as opposed to the many other contestants who are fugly for attention’s sake. These girls actually think they look GOOD, and that makes them both champions of fug, in my opinion.

    • Kit
      0

      THIS THIS THIS.

      Lilo’s may be based on the fact that she has to take free clothes from designers and they give her ill-fitting stuff that no one else wants, or it may be based on the fact that she actually picks these clothes because she thinks they look good and she may or may not be acting like she looks hot because she thinks she is or because she thinks she should – nevertheless her clothing “choices” (?) are slighlty less bad than Vanessa’s.

      But either way, Vanessa’s are bad all around, and you can tell by her face that she TOTALLY thinks she looks CUTE in them!

      Vanesssa for the win!

  32. Shahtush
    0

    Wow neck-in-neck. I just cast it for Lilo and didn’t know the tie is so tight!!! But she is just too old to be dressing that badly. It’s funny how it came down to two women who are close in age but not quite the same age group. Lilo has had a lot more opportunities working with big names and should know better. She should also be taking care of herself and stop ruining her face. Get some rest! Vanessa looks crazy most of the time, but rested.

  33. Verodemort
    0

    To quote the movie Clueless, “but are you bitches blind!?!” VHUDGE ALL THE WAY!! Those pants of Shame! The fishnets from hell! The Jessica Simpsonesque Muumuus! I mean, Lilo is probation fug. Wanna be fug. Mismanaged fug. But Vhudge thinks she looks good!! She thinks she’s a trendsetter!

  34. Adriana
    0

    Really? Just one vote difference? Be still my heart. I’m afraid that if LiLo wins, she’ll actually go to the press and gloat about this ‘popularity contest’. She seems THAT misguided.

  35. camille
    0

    I have Hudge to win (well, NOW, considering all my previous choices are gone), but honestly I’d be satisfied either way – it’s either “I’m a total stunnah” misguided depressing awfulness with Lindsay, or “lace pants the colour of your aunt’s bedroom curtains, and possibly made out of them” and other straightforward poor choices made by Hudge. Both are worthy.

    And apparently the poll feels the same way – they’re 2 votes apart!

  36. MelissaW
    0

    I never thought I’d say this but The Hudge looks pretty normal compared to the disaster that is LiLo.

    And that is sad. So, so sad.

  37. Emily
    0

    I wanted to vote for Lilo – because you can tell she really thinks that she looks good. But then the shorts that were smaller than her purse tipped the scale to V. Because I see this kind of stuff on my campus all the time and I think people are starting to think I’m crazy, as I spend all day wandering around muttering “Pants, put on some pants. You look like my grandma on acid. Pants, please for the love of God, put on pants!” And if this isn’t recognized as inappropriate and hideous soon, I’ll probably progress to yelling instead of muttering, and then they’ll lock me up. So Hudgens wins it for me, because she clearly doesn’t understand the concept of dressing like a member of society, and she doesn’t have drugs to blame.

  38. Lilo FTW
    0

    C’mon Lohan, you’ve got this! You’ve worked so hard at fugging all year long! You’ve gotten countelss hours of fuggly coaching from Dina, your “friends”, a few plastic surgeons and one hair dresser who needs an extension intervention… topped off with the worst fashion choices in the nation. That’s right, the NATION! Now get your head in the game and take Hudgens DOWN!

  39. Kimberli
    0

    The race is at 50/50! This is the closest I’ve ever seen it! Lindsay was the Pick of My Heart from the beginning, so I’m hoping she pulls it off. She has to win at something, right?

  40. Maria
    0

    Wow, I can’t believe this is a total tie. Can we proclaim them co-winners? Now I’m not going to get any work done today!!

  41. jerkygirl
    0

    Lindsay should not look like Lola from Copacabana (the old crazy Lola, not the young showgirl Lola) at her age. HER WRISTS HAVE BEARDS. BEARDS!!! Vanessa may look whack-a-doodle, but she doesn’t put me in mind of someone who’s been smoking nonfilter cigarettes and drinking gin for breakfast for the past 40 years. AND I’M ONLY TALKING ABOUT LINDSAY’S CLOTHES. Well, and those seriously misguided bleach blonde bangs. I feel sad for Lindsay too, but Vanessa’s “crazy young kid” schtick doesn’t hold a candle to Lindsay’s “do the mirrors in your house even give off reflections?” fuggery. Lindsay FTW!!!

  42. Talley
    0

    OMG! This is so close!

  43. The Ghost of Versace
    0

    This is the hardest decision ever. But my vote goes for LiLo. I found one or two of Vanessa’s outfits that I didn’t recoil in fear when I saw. Lindsay’s were all horrible. Plus her face. Oh that face could win Fug Madness on the poor plastic surgery and white hair alone.

  44. Halley
    0

    it was the fried blond hair that did it for me. For whatever else Vanessa did wrong, at least she didnt go blond! I think Lindsey is the winner just for the sizzling dye job. She looks a million times better as a red head, I am so glad someone finally convinced her of that.

  45. christa
    0

    Alright, this was hard. Here’s how I finally decided: I took a close look at all the pieces of their clothing, without thinking about their faces or bodies, and said to myself, “Self, would you ever be caught dead wearing that piece of clothing in public, whether styled and accessorized in shown manner OR any other manner?”

    And with many of Vanessa’s clothes there was stuff that I think could be made to work. And that’s just not something I can say for Lindsay’s outfits. I didn’t want to, but unfortunately I had to give it to Lindsay in the end.

  46. Michelle
    0

    I voted for Lilo simply because (as has been pointed out many times) she fancies herself a DESIGNER OF FASHION. So, addiction issues be damned; she’s earned the Fug!

  47. Nikki
    0

    As sad as it makes me, I have to vote for Lilo…. she just honestly wears her clothes with such earnestness. Hudge on the other hand, is like any other young-20-something raiding the Value Village racks for something retro and fringed. As awful as the look is, I don’t think it’s so much for fashion’s sake as it is what she thinks her lifestyle is like. Laidback, retro, smells like bong water. Poor Lindsay is trying to be stylish and relevant and fashionable, and it’s just a sad mess. I submitted my vote and it looks like the girls are tied with 50% each right now (1:48 EST) – so maybe it doesn’t matter. Can Fug Madness have a tie???

  48. Squirrel!
    0

    So, LiLo is getting a lot of sympathy NON-votes?

  49. Kris M
    0

    I don’t think that LiLo knows what planet she’s on anymore, let alone what she clothes herself with, so I think she gets off pleading insanity.
    VANESSA on the other hand. I don’t care if all the other girls at college are wearing this stuff, I’d vote for all of them to win Fug Madness. They are not 13, this is not a clothing rebellion. They are adults who should be able to find clothes that are flattering and do not look like someone accidentally washed them with a cheese grater.

  50. kim
    0

    vanessa … i feel like she’s just young, going through a phase. a hippy dippy, whacky tacky, something else that rhymes phase. lilo, though — that fug is BAKED ON.

  51. lisas
    0

    Voted Vanessa because that girl has no taste. I do like how much she loves that black fringed hippie bag though. Also, she looks like a lot of fun.

    Lindsay’s bad outfits are terrible but her good ones (there ARE good ones here and there) are pretty good. She just has no eye for colour, which is why her hair, makeup, and clothing colour choices always wash her out and look crappy.

  52. katkin74
    0

    Man, I can’t. I don’t know who to vote for! Can we have a tie? Pretty please, with a cherry on top?? I might as well flip a coin. Although someone did say something about face and hair being the deciding factor and I think that may make it so, but damn those lace pants on Vhudge are just too bad to get over. I don’t know!! I’m so CONFUSED. I think I’ll close my eyes and click something and see what happens.

  53. Rowynn
    0

    Not saying Lohan isn’t messed up, but she isn’t any crazier than Courtney Love, and Courtney gets dinged mercilessly for her weird getups. At least hers are interesting, as opposed to Lohan’s, which are just plain bad taste.

  54. Dana
    0

    Vanessa’s Joie de Fug vs. Lilo’s Eau de Desperation.

  55. Heather
    0

    I went with Hudgens, on the logic that if Lindsay had been a redhead for some (SOME) of her outfits they wouldn’t have looked as tragic because at least THAT HAIR THAT GODAWFUL HAIR would have been gone, whereas Vanessa’s outfits would’ve been awful no matter what she did with her head. So the hair was a bad decision, yeah, but Vanessa’s were a whole STRING of bad decisions that overshadowed the fact that she even HAS a head.

    • Edith
      0

      See, I feel completely opposite. I would never fug someone for having an unattractive nose, for example, but hair cut and color – and elective plastic surgery – are just as much a part of someone’s fug as their clothes. If Lilo had started with this face, I wouldn’t fug her for it, but she CHOSE AND PAID FOR THIS FACE. She chose those extensions, the ludicrous blondeness. That godawful hair was a conscious part of how she presented herself.

      • Heather
        0

        That is true; I know it can work the other way. But I feel like MORE bad decisions went into Hudge’s wardrobe.

      • Katharine
        0

        I agree with this reasoning, Edith. Lindsay has chosen the aesthetic of a Real Housewife of Beverly Hills : this is how she wants to present herself. We might miss the talented red-haired actress from Mean girls, but Lindsay has shucked off all that made her individual and compelling. I think this smug fug is more deserving of winning Fug Madness than a few dodgy choices from Vanessa Hudgens.

  56. vandalfan
    0

    THRILLING! Only two votes difference in 3,560. Proof that these two indeed are the Worthiest (?) Contenders. I have to go with LiLo, due to Slide #8. She wadded that up in the bottom of her sleeping bag last summer, and just dragged it out and put it on- without any undergarments. And some of Hudge’s stuff I have to admit I would wear, like the pink fringed coat dealie bobber.

  57. amys
    0

    I just voted, and I can’t believe it’s a straight 50/50 split. The drama!

  58. Ann
    0

    I wasn’t horrified by a few of Ole Hudge’s outfits. They weren’t *good,* mind you, just not horrifying.

    Lindsay’s were all horrifying. Lindsay for Fug Madness Winner 2012!

    • Ann
      0

      If insanity/ drug problems are disqualifications for winning Fug Madness, the Fug Girls need to revisit some of the past winners.

  59. Tracey
    0

    I don’t think this should even be a contest. Do we have misguided Vanessa fans voting FOR her? Vanessa is just a young girl making “bohemian” fashion mistakes to look cool, Lilo… the clothes, the hair, the make-up – there’s a whole lot of effort being made to look GLAMOUROUS and it just looks hideous instead.

  60. Ms.B.
    0

    I went with LiLo for the win. There is something about the Deena outfit (slide 7) that STILL makes me wince and cringe. The fabric. The high waist. The so low cut you are sure sticky tape is involved neck/chest line. And it’s jumpsuit shorts. As the tournament goes on some outfits lose their edge. There is actually one of Vanessa’s outfits I find kind of cute and another one that was a few elements off of a well played. The lace pants and canoe shorts* kept her high on my list, but they don’t outlast LiLo.

    *Canoe shorts- old cutoffs you keep around to wear over your swimsuit when you go canoeing. You want them fairly short so your legs get decent sun, but your bottom has an extra layer of protection in the canoe. Generally aren’t worn in public.

  61. ab
    0

    in the end, lilo has some drama, hudg doesn’t as far as i know. she has no crazy to blame it on.

  62. Eurydice
    0

    Had to vote for LiLo – her fuggery is both epic and long-lasting. This is practically a Lifetime Achievement Award.

  63. Lurleen
    0

    50-50. Exactly how I feel about it. Glad to see I’m not the only one. Let’s go for a tie!

  64. hope
    0

    V Hudge for the win. Everytime I saw a picture of her throughout the last year, I have said ‘what the hell is she wearing?!?”she is fug personified …stop trying to psychoanalysis Lindsey and realize that while she also looks disastrous, she sometimes wears dresses that fit her and she does not own a pr of sz100 overalls. This is why Venessa must win!

  65. Sylvia
    0

    I need to know where people go to school and see co-eds dressed like Hudgens? I’m not saying that the co-eds on my campus are fashion forward, but they do NOT dress like that, even on the hot days. Why, because even though they are Hudgens’ age, they were raised by humans and they know better. There’s just no excuse for what that young woman is doing.

    • Kit
      0

      THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS!!!!!!

      *lmao!*

      • Alix
        0

        I went to school for several years in the SEC, and NEVER saw clothes like Vanessa’s. Linday’s…different story. (Also way too many running shorts and extremely oversized t-shirts). When I transferred to a liberal arts school MUCH farther north, I was really shocked to find out people DO dress like her. More than half of the girls on campus pull out cropped tops and high waisted jean shorts (cringing while writing this sentence) to wear at the same time at the first sight of spring. They occasionally accompany those outfits with flat boots. I’m nauseous now. Excuse me. Also, excuse the CAPS.

    • thunderthighs
      0

      I taught at NYU and many of the girls dress like this. It’s straight up Urban Outfitters, American Apparel, Free People fug. I don’t like it one bit but like others have said, she’s in line with her peer group.

      And yup, booty shorts with pockets hanging out, floral cropped tops, crocheted dusters, etc. all worn frequently around campus.

  66. Tina Cortese
    0

    Gotta go with Lindsay for the win. Her crazy blonde hair & face tips it for me.

  67. rmcgrudiva
    0

    Vanessa is fun, perky, and truly happy intention, Linds is SAD intention. And I can no longer ignore the sad.

  68. Tasha D
    0

    So so close and such a tough decision. Lilo just takes it for me – at least Vanessa looks like she’s actually enjoying her fuggery.

  69. Kara
    0

    I really can’t decide and haven’t voted yet, but at least facially, Vanessa looks so much better. Lilo looks so old. In the third slide (well, in all of them, but it really jumped out at me in the third one), she looks exactly like her mother. And not “She resembles her mother very strongly” but “Wait, is that Dina?” And Dina is FORTY-NINE YEARS OLD. Vanessa’s clothes look like shit but at least she looks like the 23-year-old she is. Lilo is two years older than Vanessa and looks old enough to be her mother.

    • Ladyblahblah
      0

      I also wondered why there was a picture of Dina in slide 3 of Lindsay’s fug montage. Vanessa is obviously channeling a Deadhead circa 1978, but that’s still a much better fashion/lifestyle goal than Dina Lohan. That’s one of the main reasons that Lilo got my vote – she seems to aspire to be mistaken for a nasty over-the-hill prostitute, i.e. her mother.

  70. Ellie
    0

    I was really torn by this, but I’m going with VHudge. And the reason why is that I actually LIKE her- she’s cute and the slightly stoned neighbor analogy won me over- because some of the former Fug Madness winners have really turned it around (Hello, Solange!) and I believe in crazy Vanessa! (The Brown Pants made of Sin might’ve also swayed my vote).

    Also, I don’t want Lilo to win anything. She’s just awful.

  71. Valerie Torres
    0

    It’s neck-and-neck right now!

  72. CassieC
    0

    PLEASE, let there be some kind of show where Jean Ralphio is someone’s half-naked pool boy!

  73. Mongerel
    0

    Well, I cast my final vote in this year’s game, and I want to say Thank You to Jessica and Heather for all the work you put into this blog and in particular, the Fug Madness series. The slideshow feature made it so easy for those of us at home or work to scroll quickly through the photos, and for me, the quickness is essential to objective comparison/contrast. Plus, it’s always a joy to read the slideshow captions.

    GFY is a great site produced by great talent, and a bunch of great commenters as a bonus. Truly, whoever “wins” this competition, it’s really your readers who win here.

    THANK YOU!

    • Kimberli
      0

      I am shamelessly piggybacking my thanks onto yours because yours is lovely.

      Jessica and Heather– You do so much work for your readers and I am so appreciative. Thank you both!

  74. Kit
    0

    Just came back to check and see how it’s doing and it’s 50/50! AWESOME! *clappity clappity*

  75. Jamee
    0

    I’m with CranAppleSnapple. Lindsay is not in pain. She is a narcissistic a-hole. I do not feel sorry for her but AT ALL.

  76. Heather
    0

    I am stunned Lilo is ahead now. It’s my fault. I told my husband last night that Hudgens had it in the bag — that’s how sure I was.

    • Fanl
      0

      We all did Heather, we all did. This is a confusing time for us.

      • Hima
        0

        Heather, I think Jessica bet against you and that’s why she chose not to post the pic of Vanessa in the dress socks and strappy sandals. Every time I see that pic, I have no choice but to vote for her. Otherwise, I think I’ve become desensitized to the outfits and only see her face, which is adorable. LiLo, on the other hand, is fug all over. Clothes, hair, plastic face — all terrible.

  77. Hel
    0

    Wow! Heather really called it last year! Good foresight!

  78. Indiana Douche
    0

    Well, the cream rises to the top, they always say. In this case “cream” means Fug. Go LiLo!

  79. Red_Louise
    0

    Most of Hudge’s outfits are from off-duty days, when she clearly favours the comfy, slouchy, grungy, I-don’t-give-a-damn approach to dressing herself, like she’s happy to not make an effort when she doesn’t have to. LiLo on the other hand, is trying SO DAMN HARD all the time, clearly thinking she is bringing it, when she is so not. Also, Hudge’s hair and make-up choices are usually ok, whereas LiLo, well… GOOD GRIEF, GIRL. I fear she may have ruined her pretty face and her pretty red hair forever.

  80. Bubba
    0

    I didn’t even need to look at the photos to vote LiLo. I think this one is pretty clear cut. Vanessa looks semi-cute in a couple of those outfits.

  81. Kristina
    0

    I didn’t want to ding LiLo for her face, but it IS a new acquisition, rather than something she can’t change. Between this and that horrible video, I just feel bad for her now. Like she’s crossed some sort of rubicon, not of fugness, but of life.

  82. val.
    0

    At least VH still kind of looks cute, even in her absurd outfits. Lilo is just fug all over these days: the face, the hair, the clothes… none of it is good. So I had to go with Lilo, even though I do feel sorry for her.

    I wonder, though, if we feel sorry for her because we “knew” her as a kid. I mean, if she just suddenly popped up on the scene looking like this, she’d be Phoebe Price.

  83. Peanut
    0

    I hope that Vanessa never changes her off-duty style. She is so happy and kooky, and if she started looking normal and boring it would be tragic. She has a style, and it is not mine, and I love to see what she leaves the house in.

  84. atz
    0

    I cast my vote for LiLo, with some regret. I just see no redeeming value in any of her outfits. They are beyond hideous.

    Hudgens also has terrible taste, but a couple of her getups were only 75% bad. Lohan’s clothes, in this slideshow at least, were 100% awful. I don’t think red hair or better makeup would have made those outfits attractive. They are beyond help. Also, I really only ever see photos of celebrities on this site, so if LiLo wears nice things once in a while, I’ve never seen it.

  85. nuna
    0

    I never thought I would see this day: I agree with all the posts and can’t decide. One is too sad to make this fun, while the other is just benevolently silly. But benevolently silly is great fug, while sad is not. What a strange strange final.

  86. Charlotte
    0

    In the end it came down between Lilo’s prematurely aged face, and Vanessa’s Baggy Overalls of Shame. And while Lilo has single-handedly inspired me to start a moisturizing regimen, Vanessa’s overalls were the first fug featured on this site that ever caused me gasp out-loud. Girl, I was always the dorkiest dresser in school growing up, but I still never stooped to overalls. Either hop on a tractor or GTFO.

  87. Kendra
    0

    V-HUDGE! V-HUDGE! V-HUDGE!

    Quite honestly, voting for LiLo feels like kicking a girl when she’s down. I just don’t feel cool about it. Vanessa Hudgens fug is, like others have said, pleasantly insane and entertaining. LiLo’s fug makes me sad sad sad. What do I want to support – someone who wears hilariously kooky and cracked out clothes, and would probably laugh upon being told about her win? Or someone who’s clothes so often look/fug the way they do because a) her face is a purchased tragedy and b) she’s probably on drugs, and who I would not want to find out about this contest for fear of how they would react?

    I think it might be time to stop posting about LiLo for a while. I don’t know, I just can’t with her anymore. Too sad.

  88. Gillian
    0

    I just can’t when it comes to LiLo. It’s time to stop giving her the attention she is so desperate for. Maybe one day, she will pull a Nick Nolte or a Mickey Rourke and remind us all, she’s not just crazy. She’s crazy-talented.
    V-Hudge’s kookiness FTW!

  89. zah
    0

    sadly, i kind of like some of V-Hudge’s outfits. happily, i like none of LiLo’s. LiLo FTW.

  90. FurryPurry
    0

    I voted Lilo simply because girl is refusing to put on a bra…

    • Brio de Janeiro
      0

      @Furry Purry – I know, right? Girl’s got to be rocking a D cup. She must want to wear them on her knees in a few years.

  91. Carnac
    0

    GFY is fun! LiLo is not fun. Hence VHudge FTW!

  92. BeeDreams
    0

    I don’t think VH will fall down a shame spiral for anything other than her clothing any time soon. I’ve never seen a pic of her anywhere but appearances and with the boyf. Seems pretty tame to me. My main beef with VH (other than those lace whatever the feck you would call them, pants?) are the over the knee boots. No.

  93. Alexis
    0

    Poor, poor Lindsay Lohan. Whenever I see these pics of her all I can do is think of Mean Girls and wonder WHAT THE HELL happened to her. What a waste. She gets my vote for looking just completely cracked out, tired, insane, and for being the same weird, nicotine-stained shade of yellowy white from head to toe. Vanessa Hudgens, while she takes the grunge-boho Free People groupie (and they LOVE HER at Free People, if you don’t believe me read their blog, there are about a zillion pictures of her on it) she is at least a pretty, healthy-looking young woman with great skin and decent hair.

    • Melissa
      0

      Yeah, but all the reasons you list for voting for her are all the reasons I can’t. Too cracked out. It’s beyond fug, it’s a life in ruins.

  94. brigid
    0

    I totally agree with Alle Hall. A vote for Lindsey is a vote for her life not for her clothing. I mean really -

  95. gmol
    0

    I was torn between two fugs, but I had to go with Lilo in the end. Vanessa is young, and you know she thinks she all boho and stuff, so she can always change and get a better sylists. LL probably thinks she looks sexy,and i beg to heartily disagree. girl just looks pitiful

  96. Travis Harrison Lafferty
    0

    I’m surprised Vanessa is as tied as she is. Seriously, her clothes, while not the greatest… I feel like they kinda work for her. She looks comfortable, where as Lindsay just looks… um… well… it’s hard to say. Desperate? Washed out? A little scared? I’m not trashing the Lohan because honestly I’m totally rooting for her to get her life back together, but I feel like if she beat out ROBYN, queen of the 6th grade chili bowl haircut, then Ms. High School Musical don’t stand a chance against Ms. Parent Trap…

  97. Kristina Ma'aut Morgan
    0

    Slide 7 and 8 did it for me. Ugh! Those dresses are worse than the VH pants (or lack of pants, or even those daisy dukes, ergh!) If I was forced to wear LiLo or VH’s clothes, I’d take VH’s in a heartbeat. I’d rather eat glass than dress like LiLo.

  98. Alison
    0

    I cannot believe how close this game is. The Hudge’s reign of pants terror should be recognized for the achievement that it is. I’d take loads of LiLo’s cast offs (the white coat is okay and I think the satin blouse would have been saved with a larger size and a few open buttons), but NOTHING could convince me to put on those shorts with the pockets poking out or any of her “pants.”

  99. vandalfan
    0

    So Vanessa is Kansas and Lilo is Kentucky? And Ke shift four Ha was Louisville, and Robyn was Ohio State, I guess. It’s still a mere 20 vote difference at almost 4:30!

    Has any other Fug Madness been this close?

  100. chastity fudge
    0

    Lindsay…the face alone.

  101. Meri
    0

    Two things settled it for me: the Teen Wolf/Donatella outfit, which makes me want to kill it with fire, and VH looks so cute and happy for most of those pictures that I’m willing to forgive the innate fugliness. LiLo gets my vote!

  102. Willow
    0

    I thought Lindsay had it in the bag when she was 300 ahead but The Hudge pulled it back! This is so tense.

  103. Popcouver
    0

    Jaw just dropped at how close this race is. GOOD LORD.

  104. Jennifer Rachel Webb
    0

    I had to vote Hudge because LiLo just makes me sad. I believe Fug should bring joy to us viewers, and looking at Vanessa’s ridiculous wardrobe makes me smile. Looking at LiLo just makes me lament squandered talents. Perhaps LiLo’s overall look is truly uglier, but the Hudge embodies what this site is about.

  105. Melissa
    0

    Despite her matchless and boundless fug, I just can’t vote for Lilo. It’s too close to the bone, the girl needs help. I know she’s supposed to be doing a little better now and that’s why she’s up for fugging, but to vote for her makes ME feel a little fugly.

    Plus, Vanessa wore shorts (twice?) which look like they have a big urine-soaked landing strip. That’s some strong fug right there.

  106. liz_bee
    0

    Holy crab cakes! This is for real!

  107. Miriam
    0

    When does voting end?

  108. Jessica
    0

    Voting ends April 3 at 9am p.

  109. Kay
    0

    I think they’re both equally fugly, but I had to give the edge to LiLo because she seems to look the worst when she’s appearing at events. Vanessa Hudgens has some truly awful outfits, but she seems to wear them mostly when she’s “off duty” and not when she’s attending an event. I tend to give celebrities a break when they’re just living their lives and looking fugly.

    • Dani
      0

      How much is that what was chosen for the slides though? V-Hudge had some truely hideous red carpet moments too. Mainly when she had that terrible short hair that made her look 45yo.

  110. Maretha2
    0

    I can’t believe only 30 votes is currently separating these two! This looks like the closest Fug Madness vote I can ever remember.

    I voted for Hudgens. Since she seems mentally and emotionally stable, she should have the wherewithal to dress her cute self in *something* that doesn’t resemble an Olsen Twin reject garment. Poor Lilo does not seem capable of remembering to even get fully dressed in the morning, so I almost feel like it’s an accomplishment for her if she leaves the house with both tops and bottoms on, no matter how fugly.

  111. Cynthia Coles
    0

    Check this out – everyone on the fence in the final hours of voting:

    Lindsay Lohan’s Changing Face – 25 Years in 60 seconds morph
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_0Mi5Q-ExZ8

    • jean
      0

      Shudder. With pity. That’s a PSA if I ever saw one.

    • Akit
      0

      To Cynthia Coles – Brilliant link! spooky but brilliant!

    • Donna
      0

      Holy crap! That is so sad. She was the cutest, healthiest looking kid, and then…

      I now feel bad that I voted for her. Seriously, Cynthia and other members of Fug Nation, you have changed my stance on thinking that she was deserving of my vote just because she’s a celebrity and puts herself out there. I actually feel bad.

      And re Vanessa: when I was in my very early twenties I was really into the hippy look (though god forbid anyone dared “label” me) and she’ll get over it and have a chuckle about some of her outfits later.

  112. anny
    0

    Remember: If history repeats itself, which it is wont to do, the winner of this goes away from the public eye and gets her sh*t together.

    Lilo: the compassionate choice.

  113. corriner
    0

    “I’m blogging in this right now!” may possibly be the funniest comment this entire round of Fug Madness.

    The utter ridiculousness of what The Hudge wears takes it for me-I read an interview where she talks about how much she loves clothes from the 70s and loves to put together outfits….so this is premeditated.

    and LiLo just makes me sad.

  114. Unstable Isotope
    0

    This one is genuinely difficult. LiLo just looks so all-over fug whereas VHudge looks happy. The lace pants of doom and the weird hair chain almost tipped it to the Hudge but I voted for LiLo for her overall body of work.

  115. Kelly
    0

    In the end, nothing in the Hudge file even comes close to Lilo’s boobtastic jumpsuit. She takes it all on the strength of that alone.

  116. Fiona K
    0

    This one is a real nail biter! I keep checking in and it’s 50/50. The suspense!

  117. Sandi
    0

    I had to vote for LiLo–not because I wanted to, but because even though Vanessa Hudgens has terrible taste, she at least has style. I am not voting based on physical appearance–we are not here to body snark.

  118. Damian
    0

    One vote difference! The Hudgens should win!

  119. mai
    0

    Both sets of outfits are fugly, but Vanessa at least looks her age, whereas Lindsay looks like mutton dressed as lamb. A remarkable achievement considering she is still a lamb. LiLo all the way!

  120. Veronica
    0

    Even though most of her ensembles don’t come together, I think Hudgens actually has hints of a style underneath. There’s definitely a retro-hippie look she seems to like, and with a little time and maturation, I could see that becoming refined into something a little more practical. Lilo, however, is a lost cause even before it becomes one.

  121. sarky
    0

    If Lindsay wins does she become Filo?

  122. Charlotte
    0

    It’s been going back and forth between Lilo and VH all evening! I’ve been refreshing the page every hour and the lead always changes. I am officially more enthralled – and anxious – with this final showdown than I have been with any sports match, ever.

  123. TonyG
    0

    Voted for The Vudge. The depth of her fug outdoes LiLo. The Vudge mixed and matched her fug to a level that LiLo simply did not achieve.

  124. jean
    0

    Vanessa for the win! She’s happy fug! Not tragic fug. And I do feel like she represents the worst of all fashionable trends right now except she hasn’t messed with her face or gone on a fad diet. She’s just a hot mess of trends. And someday she’ll either be Katie Holmes or Juliette Lewis (but I hope she goes the Juliet route–Juliet seems happy).

  125. Verodemort
    0

    I have literally voted for the Hudge from FOUR different computers and all for not :(

    • CranAppleSnapple
      0

      Nought. :)

      • vandalfan
        0

        Naught.

        Further, your affiant sayeth naught. ;-)

      • CranAppleSnapple
        0

        Middle English noght, from Old English nōwiht, which in turn comes from ne-ō-wiht which was a phrase used as an emphatic no meaning “not a thing”. Eventually this degenerated into ‘nought’, ‘nawt’ and then ‘not’. :)

  126. jean
    0

    Hey Jessica and Heather, what if you switched around the pictures and showed Vanessa first? Are people even clicking through all the way to her? Or do every other. Just wondering (and I guess hoping for a miracle win by Hudge).

  127. Mooshki
    0

    I’m still sad that Kourtney didn’t make the finals. :( She was robbed!

  128. Akit
    0

    LiLo all the way, she’s old(er) enough to know better.

  129. Sajorina
    0

    Vanessa FUGdgens FTW!!! Come on, she ALWAYS looks like she got dressed in the dark… in a traveling circus’ performers’ dressing room… in the 70s! Her wardrobe is APPALING! She assaults my eyes and crushes my soul with her FUG! Eeeeewwwww!!!!!

    So sad that this is not an actual award, so I could take it and beat some sense into her with it!

  130. Franziska
    0

    I had to go with LiLo. Because she always ALWAYS looks like she’s in dire need of a bath. Plus, she’s older than Hudgens, she should know better.

  131. lesli
    0

    We’ve only seen the same few outfits from LiLo and several different fugly ones from Vanessa. I saw some in this slide show I hadn’t seen before! But the SAME ONES for LiLo that have been posted EVERY TIME. Let’s hear it for quality AND quantity! VOTE FOR THE HUDGE!

  132. lesli
    0

    LiLo is ONLY TWO YEARS OLDER than Vanessa!

  133. Wendy Powers
    0

    Lilo loses based on her hair alone. Full on FUGLY!!

  134. Karen
    0

    Please, please, Fug Girls – if Lindsey is still alive next year just leave her out of Fug Madness. I can’t bear kicking someone when she’s down.

    • Mahastee
      0

      Yes. This. I think the Fug Girls (and 49-51% of Fug Nation) really must not care about mental & physical well-being. I am disappointed, I thought we were better than that.

      If this is the acceptable standard, why wasn’t Whitney Houston given a posthumous seeding?

      • CranAppleSnapple
        0

        Someone who rights f-u on her fingernail so she can flip off a Judge while in court being tried for criminal offences, is actually a sociopathic narcissist who thinks the world revolves around her. We should feel sorry for her for that?

      • CranAppleSnapple
        0

        Writes. sigh.

      • Edith
        0

        Wow. Back the truck up. Just because I don’t have a problem declaring Lindsay’s clothes überfug in a contest on the internet does not mean I “must not care about mental & physical well-being..” That’s a HUGE leap. This is fug madness, it isn’t a test of our compassion. We are NOT IN HER LIFE, we are commenting on the clothes she wore to photocalls, on the internet. We are not dissecting her mental state, or snarking cruelly about her body. We are talking about the clothes, hair and makeup. I don’t presume to know her motivations, even though she’s a public figure. Please don’t presume to know MINE in voting for her.

      • Sajorina
        0

        @CranAppleSnapple: Calling Lindsay a “sociopathic narcissist” is WAY OUT OF LINE! I doubt you’re a Forensic Psychologist or a Psychiatrist; and, even if you were, how could you diagnose someone you don’t know and have never treated? Just SHUT IT!

      • CranAppleSnapple
        0

        Um no, I will not shut it.
        I base my opinion on every crappy thing she did while in court and the crimes she committed to GET there. Go ahead and ignore her criminal record and the fact that she tried to run down a baby with her car. Enabler.

        And go yell at someone else, jackass.

      • Heather
        0

        Please stop with the name calling, and with telling people to “shut it.” Neither are accepted behaviour in our comments, no matter how long you’ve been here, so please take it elsewhere.

        @Mahastee, I think you’re being a little extreme. We have left out Britney, Rihanna, Bai Ling, and others due to ongoing concerns. The trouble with Lindsay is, she insists she has none. And insists, and insists, and insists. And there’s a point at which I say, “Okay, kid, that’s how you want to play it? Fine. We’ll play.” If she is actively in rehab and/or in the process of dealing with serious issues, we consider eliminating someone from contention. But until then, I don’t know her life. I can only guess, and if she’s going to insist to the world that she’s awesome, well, what else can I do? Frankly, half this town probably has issues that they just hide better, if you want to go down THAT slippery slope.

  135. Share
    0

    Lilo earned this one.

  136. Britt
    0

    I believe that I have finally found my fugging philosophy.

    Grouchy fug beats joyful fug beats sad fug. In this case, Vanessa wins, because she at least seems to be having a good time, while Lilo just makes me sad.

    The moral dilemmas we face in today’s world! :)

    • Britt
      0

      But I would like to add that I think it’s awesome how close this has become. It’s cool to see that we all think differently.

  137. Kait
    0

    HUDGENS FANS UNITE!

    • Sajorina
      0

      I’m not a fan of Fugdgens, that’s why I voted for her… I can’t stand her & her FUG!

  138. ML
    0

    For me, Lilo deserves to cut down the Fug Madness hoop net because of these two things:

    1. Dina Lohan, Party Mom
    2. Looking exactly like the “Valley of the Dolls” reference in the one post

    Also, I’m tired of seeing Skinny Jeans Ken as an accessory in nearly all the Hudge pix. He bugs.

    Lilo needs a win, Fugmerica. Give her onnnnnnnnnnnnne mo-mennnnnnnnnt INNNNNNN tiiiiiiiii-me…

  139. Kit
    0

    I can’t believe it’s 50/50 again. I checked about an hour ago and Lilo was ahead by 30 or so!

  140. Ann
    0

    Whoa. I think voting is closed and it’s a FIFTY/ FIFTY TIE. What to do? High drama in Fug Nation today, fug fans!

  141. Jill
    0

    It’s 50/50, but the Hudge has a handful more votes. Surprised as I was sure LiLo would end up taking it.

  142. DT
    0

    I DEMAND A RECOUNT! please :)

  143. annek
    0

    I voted for Lilo in earlier matchups exactly for the reason many have mentioned — the fug winner tends to disappear for a while, and Lilo needs nothing so much as some peaceful time off. But then I thought, oh no, what if she disappears because she DIES! then I would feel I had contributed to her downfall.

  144. Julie
    0

    Voting is still open?! I had Lilo in my brackets as Fug Champion. And she was winning when I thought the polls closed. But now she’s losing. So close…

  145. Willow
    0

    That was so freaking close! But yay, finally the person I picked from the beginning won!

  146. ML
    0

    Looking ahead, I’m already putting odds on ole Horselaugh Rimes and the Skin-Graft Dress going deep in next year’s tourney. Something tells me she’s bent, damned and determined to be seen and fugged this year wherever and whenever there’s a camera at the ready.

  147. dee
    0

    Ohh I had the voting screen open while I deliberated, and somewhere in the last 15 min the vote window closed. I still dont know who I would have voted for….*torn*

  148. Edith
    0

    I call shenanigans!

  149. Sweetsinger
    0

    Fug Madness 2012: in like a lion, out like a lamb. The final contestants are so boring I didn’t bother to vote.

  150. Alison
    0

    I’d like to congratulate our fugly contestants for a well played and exciting match up. I thought it’d be a landslide, but these two were more evenly matched than I’d thought.

  151. Kimberli
    0

    Nooooo! I believed in you, Lindsay!

  152. Chaiaiai
    0

    I am just pleased that yesterday’s match was ALSO on Brown Peldon’s birthday.

    And thank you Heather and Jessica, y’all are the best!

  153. annek
    0

    Heather and Jessica, my beloved girls who add the spice to fug that makes it palatable… thank you so much for another tournament of laughs, tears, coffee-out-of-nose guffaws, and witty repartee. Wish y’all lived next door to me so we could hang. THANK YOU!

  154. Val
    0

    Damnit, I miss SWINTON.

  155. c
    0
  156. CranAppleSnapple
    0

    Apologies to the site.

    I was just defending myself after being yelled at,
    and defending the 50% of the voters who voted for Lilo, who had been told we were heartless to do so because she’s a fragile flower, not a selfish criminal.

  157. Anne
    0

    Not the Beatles! Apologies if I’m the gazillioneth person to say this, but I just noticed that in the shot where V-Hudge is wearing the Heinous, Foot-Swallowing Lace Pants of Horror, the picture on her tshirt is not the Beatles on Abbey Road. If they were, the third guy in the line would be Paul wearing a black suit. Who are these people, and why are they okay with those pants????