Best and Worst Emmys Run-Off


Because it was really too close to call in both these races at end of day in the giant-massive-insane-huge poll yesterday. Vote, friends! VOTE FOR TRUTH!

Who was the best dressed at the Emmys this year?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Who was the worst dressed at the Emmys this year?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
react:
Leave a reply

Comments (53):

  1. kmg
    0

    Tina Fey looks great, I love her and her dress. I can’t see how Ashley Judd looked in the mirror and thought that hair was OK. Her dress was meh but it’s the hair that makes her worst dressed for me.

  2. Tina Thompson
    0

    I’m conflicted on worse. Is Portia’s worse, because I expect better of her, and she usually looks great? Or, is it just the attitude/facial gyrations/hair/umbrella debacle that Ashley Judd presents? Decisions, decisions…

    • Kat
      0

      I think in reality, Portia’s is worse, but the smug look on Ashley’s face just puts it over the top for me. Ugly smug = FUGLY.

  3. Chris
    0

    Tina I guess, but there’s something about her hair there I don’t like

  4. Donna
    0

    I would’ve unreservedly loved Leslie Mann’s entire look if she had some red lippy on, to help make the yellow and turquoise really pop.

    As for Ashley Judd, I can’t look at her without thinking of Mars Attack!, which I love, so just for that I’d like to vote her best-dressed.

  5. Dyanna
    0

    How is it possible that DISHWATER LACE JUMPSUIT is trumped by BIG HAIR BRIDESMAID?

    • S
      0

      dishwater lace jumpsuit would have been rocked by Helen Gurley Brown or an eqiuvalent teensy audacious older woman. No one could look good in that dress, especially with that hair. (Ashley, fellow Ashland Tomcat, I still heart you!)

  6. aeb
    0

    i voted for ashley judd, but might disagree with my decision. i think she did this as a joke. portia de rossi on the other hand, not a joke.

    and leslie mann is a winner no matter what the votes say!

  7. Amanda
    0

    I will never be able to decide if Ashley Judd or Portia was worst dressed. It is too much to ask. I can’t handle it.

  8. Prolixity Julien
    0

    Who would have thought that Tina Fey would be in the best dressed race? Originally, I voted for Leslie Mann, but this time I gave it to Tina because she wasn’t there as someone’s moral support, but as a performer and that struck me as more in the spirit of GFY. It nearly killed me not to vote for Naeem Kahn anything though.

    Was there some cartoon where an adorable kitten wore a huge bow? For some reason, that is all I can picture when I see Ashley Judd.

  9. Eliza Bennett
    0

    y’all, Tina Fey looks hella hot. Her hair is off, but come on. That is delectable. Leslie Mann’s is good and would be even better if her top didn’t make me think she was nekkid or covered in L’egg’s pantyhose with beading.

  10. Lucille Austero
    0

    I simply cannot decide between Tina Fey and Leslie Mann. Can we pleeeeease award Best Dressed to both of them? Portia de Rossi for worst dressed. I think Ashley Judd’s hair is tipping the scales unfairly. Like I said before, her hair deserves a category all to itself.

  11. Claire
    0

    I betcha that if Portia wins the coveted title, Ellen will call out the Fug girls on her show, which will lead to their appearance on the show in a good-natured game show segment.

  12. Wendy
    0

    In spite of Ashely’s hair and stupid bow, I had to give worst dressed to Portia. At least Ashley’s was a pretty color and she seemed to be having fun and be proud of her look. Portia’s “outfit” on the other hand had absolutely no redeeming qualities whatsoever.

  13. carolyn
    0

    Leslie Mann is getting robbed! The back was fab too. TIna looks great but not AS great.
    IMHO Heidi was more FUG than both the finalists so I will refrain from voting!

  14. DanerKebab
    0

    Had to go with Portia for worst dressed, because at least pink is a decent color on Ashley. There are no redeeming qualities to Portia’s look.

  15. DanerKebab
    0

    Also, I’m not convinced Tina’s dress is a half-to-full size too small. On TV, her boobs looked squished, and she didn’t look like she was able to move much.

    • DanerKebab
      0

      *isn’t. I’m not convinced it isn’t too small.

    • Annie S.
      0

      Agreed. All I could think as I watched the telecast was how difficult it must be to walk in that gown. Gorgeous, but definitely too tight.

  16. Jennifer
    0

    Ashley Judd was the Worst, but it was a funny worst!! I kind of like her more for wearing this silly dress and hair, and in that bright easter-egg color, and seeming to enjoy it. Tough call between Leslie Mann and Tina Fey. Leslie Mann dress pops in that bright marigold, and the whole look balances elegance and carefreeness perfectly. But Tina Fey– she’s just come so far. She looks so pristine and classic and elegant. I have to give her Best!!

  17. Sandra
    0

    I had a hard time choosing between Fey and Mann, but Leslie has her hands in her damn pockets and I hate that with formal wear. So she loses the crown by about half a point.

    Ashley Judd does look like a Conehead prom chaperone, but Portia de Rossi looks like she has had rectangles cut out of her torso. Her own, I mean, not the top of the suit.

  18. Lindy
    0

    I do not get all the love for Tina Fey’s dress. It’s FINE but in no way close to “best dressed.”

    • Ann
      0

      Sadly, I agree. I think it’s because Fey’s so generally wonderful and also generally misses the mark when it comes to formal wear. I think everyone’s just… relieved. It would be like if Bai Ling wore a nice formal gown and a subdued updo. You just want to cheer.

    • Ryan
      0

      I don’t even like the dress really (the neckline is weird and the bottom of it is dull) but I still voted for her for best dressed in the first poll because it does such good things for her figure and the colour is really nice on her, and no one else really stood out or excited me (except Sofia Vergara who looked ridiculously hot obviously but it was maybe a bit too much).

  19. sharjem
    0

    My husband just looked over my shoulder and asked whether Portia di Rossi’s Austrian nanny made her a jumpsuit out of drapes.

  20. pax
    0

    Tina looks very nice but that is a dress I’ve seen a million times before. Leslie looks fab and also interesting and refreshing. I love Tina but if she wins she will sit on a throne of lies.

  21. Nancy
    0

    I like Tina’s, but I LOVE the other dress. Tina’s is much more predictable, while the other dress is so unusual, and sunny! I love it more than almost any other dress I have seen in a long while!!

    I thought Ashley Judd was joking with that outfit, no??

  22. Amalia
    0

    Tina looks fab. The fabbest she has ever looked anytime in public and if you happen to look through her archives you will gasp at how far she has come. It’s not that I don’t like L.Mann’s outfit, but it is a bit costumey by comparison. That wipes out her bonus points for good use of turquoise.

  23. Aria
    0

    I think Tina looks the best I’ve seen her, but I still can’t vote her best-dressed; i don’t love the neckline of the dress. LOVE Leslie Mann’s whole look.

    Ashley’s dress is not my fave (and hair is obviously awful) but she at least looks like she gave some effort. Portia’s beige pantsuit is ugly, like she gave no thought to the event she was attending, and her hair looks like she’s been in a wind tunnel. Worst is def Portia.

  24. Vickie
    0

    I can’t vote for Portia…she looks like she’s suffering another bout with anorexia…so sad. So I’m going with the crazy hair of Ms. Judd.

  25. Vickie
    0

    Couldn’t vote for Leslie Mann because of the work out hairdo. So Tina Fey it is~

  26. Cristina
    0

    While Leslie Mann’s dress is more beautiful than Tina Fey’s, I feel like with Mann, I’m looking at her dress, while with Fey’s, I’m looking at HER, and she LOOKS SPECTACULAR. So the more boring dress wins.

  27. Sandala
    0

    Has Portia done something to her face? Please say its a wonky picture and that this beautiful girl hasn’t decided she needed to botox / freeze / fill / pull it.

  28. Lisa
    0

    I’m definitely grading on a curve here. Tina Fey is looking so much better than she has in the past, whereas Leslie Mann routinely kills it. (In fact, I’ve liked some of her other outfits in the past better than this one–hands out of pocket, lady!)

    As for worst, I have to give it to Ashley Judd. She is indeed looking smugly. I even covered up her hair, and I still think that dress is fug.

  29. Carrie
    0

    I think Tina Fey LOOKS great, but the dress itself is pretty average IMO. Leslie is doing something great in that she not only looks pretty, but the dress is interesting and the accessories are effing fantastic. I chose Ashley for worst dressed, but unlike most people, it’s actually LESS for the hair and more for that awful, stiff, bridesmaid/caketopper dress with the christmas ornament hanger on the back. Dreadful.

  30. Ms. Chanandler Bong
    0

    I don’t think either of them are Best Dressed, but I voted for Tina because this is the best she’s ever looked at an awards show. My personal choice was Jessica Pare. I loved the whole thing from head to toe.

  31. ajm262
    0

    Here’s the thing, Leslie Mann looks exquisite, and I think her styling is perfect and FUN, but Tina Fey is always such a disappointment that I have to give this one to her as a most improved.

  32. hillpagan
    0

    Are you kidding? Ashley Judd should win for best dressed! Or there should be a separate category for funniest! Now way is she anywhere near the bottom!

    • Jessica
      0

      These run -offs are happening because of the way Fug Nation voted. I didn’t just pick ‘em out of a hat!

  33. Kyasarin
    0

    Maybe I’m just wrong, but I am not a fan of Leslie Mann’s dress. It looks like a glass of Tang with a doily on top. Tina, however, looks perfect.

  34. Shanti
    0

    Couldn’t vote to fug Ashley Judd – that outfit and bouffant hair are just way too hilariously awesome to fug. Also, Portia is far too beautiful for that hideous getup.

  35. M.Amanda
    0

    Tina and Portia get the votes from me not because of their outfits, but because of action. I can forgive a silly look if it’s played for humor as Ashley appeared to do. Portia seems to have misguidedly taken a risk that did not go over well at all. And I love Leslie. Really. She looks great. She seems like a very cool person. BUT. For the love of fashion, I don’t care how cool you think it is that your gown has POCKETS, do not – DO NOT – pose for photographs with your hands crammed into them.

  36. nmlhats
    0

    These are not the best to me nor the worst, so I can’t even vote in good conscience.

  37. Sajorina
    0

    Kat Dennigs is still the BEST DRESSED for me & Zosia Mamet is still the WORST! This doesn’t change my mind at all!

  38. Bottle Ginger
    0

    Tina wins “best dressed’ because Leslie’s beautiful dress was beautiful… but it wasn’t flattering.

    Yellow is an awkward color for blondes, too bright a shade can make even the brightest hair look dull, as is the case here. Sure, the brightest yellow wasn’t actually near her hair, but her hair still looked dull because it was in the same pictures as that brilliant sunflower yellow! (And her complexion didn’t look much better.)

    Tina’s dress was also beautiful, but it was as flattering as hell. It gave her glowing skin, and a bombshell figure.

  39. miss_msry
    0

    Some women just give up once they get married.

  40. miss_msry
    0

    Hard to call, because all of them look AWESOME!!!!

    Including the every lovely Elen.

  41. johnnycakes
    0

    Tina Fey gets my vote for best dressed because—well she’s Tina Fey! ’nuff said.
    What’s up with that Portia chick’s dress/pants suit? weird is what comes to mind. who let her out of the house looking like that?